Litigation Highlight: Duncan v. Becerra
In March, a federal district court in California became the first federal court in the land to strike down a ban on large-capacity magazines. In a striking opinion stretching for 86 pages, Judge Roger Benitez touted the timeless principles of “[i]ndividual liberty and freedom” when he held that California could not constitutionally prohibit the transfer or possession of magazines holding more than 10 rounds. Now, that case is on appeal in Ninth Circuit.
The government’s opening brief is here. The challengers’ response brief—filed just yesterday—is here. What’s noteworthy is that a new attorney has entered an appearance for the challengers: Paul Clement, a powerhouse Supreme Court litigator who is the only advocate in the past decade to successfully convince the Court to hear a Second Amendment challenge. He’s scheduled to argue the most recent challenge, New York City Rifle & Pistol Association v. City of New York, on December 2 of this year. Whatever happens in NYSRPA, the Duncan case out of California is certainly one to watch.